For over 25 years, Arnie and Jesse Peltz have been helping seniors navigate Medicare with honesty, expertise, and a personal touch that big agencies can’t match.
Our Story
Plans Plus for Seniors was founded by Arnie Peltz with a straightforward mission: give seniors honest, expert guidance on Medicare — without the pressure, confusion, or hidden agendas that too often come with insurance.
When Jesse joined his father in the business, it became a true family operation. As a father-and-son team, Arnie and Jesse bring a shared commitment to treating every client like a member of their own family.
As independent brokers, they don’t work for any insurance company. They work for you. That means their only job is to compare plans from 30+ carriers and recommend the coverage that best fits your needs and budget — not the plan that pays them the highest commission.
And their service doesn’t end after enrollment. Every year, they conduct a free annual review of all the products you’ve purchased through them — Medicare Supplement, Medicare Advantage, Part D, Critical Illness, Dental/Vision/Hearing, Life Insurance — everything. If a better plan exists, they’ll find it for you.
Arnie Peltz
Founder
Jesse Peltz
Co-Founder
Meet the Team
A father-and-son team with one shared mission: putting your interests first, every single time.
Founder & Medicare Specialist
Arnie founded Plans Plus with a simple belief: seniors deserve an advocate who puts their interests first. With over 25 years of experience in insurance and financial services, Arnie has guided thousands of clients through Medicare enrollment, plan changes, and annual reviews. His deep knowledge of the insurance landscape and his genuine care for every client make him the trusted advisor families return to year after year.
Co-Founder & Medicare Specialist
Jesse joined the family business to carry forward its mission of putting clients first. A licensed Medicare specialist in all 50 states, Jesse combines deep product knowledge with a modern, technology-driven approach to helping seniors find the right coverage. He is known for his patience in explaining complex options in plain language, his responsiveness, and his commitment to reviewing every client’s coverage annually to ensure they always have the best plan at the best price.
We believe every senior deserves an advocate who will fight for the best coverage at the best price — and then check back every year to make sure it’s still the right fit.
Why Choose Us
We do things differently — and our clients notice.
We are not employed by any insurance company. We represent you, not the carrier. Our recommendations are based solely on what is best for your health and your wallet.
We compare plans from over 30 top-rated insurance companies to find the best fit for your coverage needs and budget. More options mean better results for you.
We review ALL your plans every year — Medicare, CHS, DVH, Life Insurance — everything. If a better option exists, we find it and switch you at no cost.
Licensed in all 50 states + D.C. We serve clients by phone and video no matter where you live. Focus states include NY, FL, NC, SC, GA, NJ, CT & TX.
Our services are completely free. We are compensated by the insurance carriers — you pay nothing extra. The price is the same whether you go direct or through us.
You’ll always talk to Jesse or Arnie — never a call center or chatbot. We take the time to understand your situation and answer every question.
What Our Clients Say
Don’t take our word for it — hear from the seniors we serve every day.
“Plans Plus for Seniors, Arnie and Jesse Peltz, have been the best insurance agents I have ever had... They give the most personalized service, never rush me, always promptly get back to me, and go above and beyond...”
New York
“My wife and I have been with Plans Plus for many years... Both Arnie and Jesse have guided us through our insurance needs with excellent and courteous advice.”
Long Island, NY
“I have been having a very good relationship with Jesse for 7 years. He always has time to detail different health plans...”
Fort Lauderdale, FL
“Plans Plus for Seniors is a highly professional and caring service... We have used their expertise for years and have been consistently very satisfied...”
Ridgewood, NJ
Schedule a free, no-obligation consultation with Jesse or Arnie. We’ll review your current coverage, compare your options, and make sure you have the best plan at the best price.